WV Supreme Court: HOA can represent condo owners - WTRF 7 News Sports Weather - Wheeling Steubenville

WV Supreme Court: HOA can represent condo owners

Posted: Updated:
  • BusinessBusinessMore>>

  • 'Downtown Wheeling Inc.' Changes Name, Still Has Same Goals

    'Downtown Wheeling Inc.' Changes Name, Still Has Same Goals

    Thursday, August 21 2014 3:16 PM EDT2014-08-21 19:16:18 GMT
    One popular organization in Wheeling has changed their name. "Downtown Wheeling Inc.," will now be known as "Reinvent Wheeling." The group hosts many events in the Wheeling area such as the Wine and Jazz Festival, the Big Ideas Speaker series, and First Fridays. According to Reinvent Wheeling member Jake Dougherty, the name change is intended to reflect the organizations efforts to revitalize the downtown area. He said, "We were looking for a name that really expresses what was happening in d...
    One popular organization in Wheeling has changed their name. "Downtown Wheeling Inc.," will now be known as "Reinvent Wheeling." The group hosts many events in the Wheeling area such as the Wine and Jazz Festival, the Big Ideas Speaker series, and First Fridays. According to Reinvent Wheeling member Jake Dougherty, the name change is intended to reflect the organizations efforts to revitalize the downtown area. He said, "We were looking for a name that really expresses what was happening in d...
  • US existing home sales rise for 4th straight month

    US existing home sales rise for 4th straight month

    Thursday, August 21 2014 10:33 AM EDT2014-08-21 14:33:29 GMT
    Sales of existing U.S. homes rose for the fourth straight month in July to their highest level in nearly a year, the latest sign that the housing recovery is picking up after stumbling at the start of the year.
    Sales of existing U.S. homes rose for the fourth straight month in July to their highest level in nearly a year, the latest sign that the housing recovery is picking up after stumbling at the start of the year.
  • 2014 West Virginia Broadband Conference highlights NTIA grant

    2014 West Virginia Broadband Conference highlights NTIA grant

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 3:13 PM EDT2014-08-20 19:13:42 GMT
    At the West Virginia Broadband Conference: Investing in the Future, at the Charleston Mariott Town Center Aug. 19, presenters highlighted the multiple sectors in the Mountain State's 11 planning and development regions that received monetary funds through a grant by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration of the United State Department of Commerce.
    At the West Virginia Broadband Conference: Investing in the Future, at the Charleston Mariott Town Center Aug. 19, presenters highlighted the multiple sectors in the Mountain State's 11 planning and development regions that received monetary funds through a grant by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration of the United State Department of Commerce.
  • GovernmentGovernmentMore>>

  • City of Bridgeport to participate in Internet pilot program

    City of Bridgeport to participate in Internet pilot program

    Thursday, August 21 2014 1:42 PM EDT2014-08-21 17:42:43 GMT
    House Speaker Tim Miley, D-Harrison, applauded bold steps by the city of Bridgeport to become in providing residents with a huge boost in Internet speed. Miley, in a press release, also urged other West Virginia communities to consider a similar approach.
    House Speaker Tim Miley, D-Harrison, applauded bold steps by the city of Bridgeport to become in providing residents with a huge boost in Internet speed. Miley, in a press release, also urged other West Virginia communities to consider a similar approach.
  • WV Sen. Manchin applauds DEA decision to reschedule hyrdocodone, related drugs

    WV Sen. Manchin applauds DEA decision to reschedule hyrdocodone, related drugs

    Thursday, August 21 2014 11:56 AM EDT2014-08-21 15:56:04 GMT
    The U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration moved Aug. 21 to list hydrocodone-combination products as Schedule II drugs under the Controlled Substance Act. U.S. Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., applauded the DEA after the agency officially announced the final rule to reschedule the drugs, which are found in highly addictive painkillers like Vicodin and Lortab, from a Schedule III to a Schedule II controlled substance.
    The U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration moved Aug. 21 to list hydrocodone-combination products as Schedule II drugs under the Controlled Substance Act. U.S. Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., applauded the DEA after the agency officially announced the final rule to reschedule the drugs, which are found in highly addictive painkillers like Vicodin and Lortab, from a Schedule III to a Schedule II controlled substance.
  • National Parks Service bans drones over Appalachian Trail

    National Parks Service bans drones over Appalachian Trail

    Thursday, August 21 2014 11:49 AM EDT2014-08-21 15:49:23 GMT
    National Park Service photoNational Park Service photo
    The National Park Service has banned drones from flying over the Appalachian Trail.
    The National Park Service has banned drones from flying over the Appalachian Trail.

A home owners association can represent two or more home owners in litigation even if damages affect individual units, West Virginia Supreme Court justices recently said, answering a certified question coming out of Monongalia County Circuit Court. 

Justice Allen Loughry delivered the March 28 opinion of the court in the case of University Commons Riverside Home Owners Association Inc. v. University Common Morgantown, Koehler Development LLC, Collegiate Homes Inc., Richard Koehler, Frank Koehler, Adam Sharp, Richard Dunlap, OC Cluss Professional Services LLC, RE Crawford Construction Inc., Pozzuto and Sons Inc., Building Code Enforcement Official of Star City, Herron Engineering, Eagle Interiors Inc., Buh Construction, Triad Engineering Inc. and Universal Forest Products. 

In the suit, which justices referred to the mass litigation panel, the HOA brought legal action on behalf of 84 condo owners at the University Condominium Complex near West Virginia University. 

In its brief to the Supreme Court, the association alleged defendants built "a financial, structural and environmental disaster that will cost millions of dollars to repair." 

Some of the problems the association allege include improper drainage of water in and around the building and foundation, malfunctioning sewer pump lift stations, defective and improperly installed HVAC mechanical system, stone facades falling away form the building and visible and latent mold growth. 

However, defendants argue not everyone is experiencing problems, noting that only 21 of the 84 units identified problems in their HVAC system. 

"The HOA has been inconsistent in its representative claims and the defendants must be permitted to depose not only those unit owners with complaints but those without complaints in order to determine whether, for example, improper maintenance is a factor in the inconsistent complaints," defendants state in their state Supreme Court brief. 

Some of the defendants made a motion in November 2010 to have all the owners joined as plaintiffs, saying the home owners' association doesn't have the authority to pursue claims for damages to individual units. 

"The unit owners are necessary parties to this lawsuit and, without their involvement, the defendants are open to substantial risk of incurring multiple suits with the possibility of inconsistent adjudication," defendants argued in their brief.

The association moved for a protective order in 2011, seeking protection of its right to bring a suit on behalf of its members. 

The lower court denied the association's protective order and certified the six questions to the state Supreme Court. The lower court found that the association can only bring action on behalf of its members if it affects the "common interest community." 

The court additionally ruled the association could not represent owners on damages to individual units. 

Justices answered the first question, saying that a home owners' association can represent two or more unit owners in litigation when damages only affect individual units.  

Justices said "it is clear that the units are part of the common interest community." 

"Thus a purchaser of a condominium unit owns his or her individual unit along with an undivided interest in the ‘common elements' defined as ‘all portions of the common interest community other than the units,'" the opinion states. 

"Given the fact that a unit is a physical portion of the common interest community, it necessarily follows that damages only affecting individual units are nonetheless matters affecting the common interest community," justices wrote. 

Justices deferred other questions to the mass litigation panel, saying although there are not multiple lawsuits in this case, the legal action does involve multiple allegations asserted by multiple individuals. 

"We find that the only way to maintain fair standards of procedure in this instance is to transfer this case to the mass litigation panel," justices said.